There had only been one man in her life since Josh Nelson.
He was an education student at University of Portland, a safe, predictable man who adored her. They met their freshmen years and dated on and off until they graduated. With Larry she would’ve been loved and cherished all her life, but there was one problem.
It wasn’t magical.
Amanda pulled into her parents’ driveway and went inside. She had dinner with them every Thursday night since she and Larry broke up. Dinner was often the same – salmon or chicken, and when the meal was over, her father would slip into the television room for a sports update, and she and her mother would sip tea and talk.
That night, Amanda wasted no time. “Tell me something.” She put the kettle on and turned her back to the stove. “What did you think of Larry?”
Her mother cast her a sideways look. “I thought he was nice.”
“He was.” Amanda pulled her loose dark curls back and brought them over one shoulder. “He still calls once in a while.”
“Are you thinking about him again?” She put her plate in the dishwasher and took two clean mugs from the cupboard.
“No.” The stove was heating up. Amanda moved over a few inches. “Something was missing with Larry.”
“Something’s missing with most people, darling.” Her mother sat at one of the kitchen barstools and faced her. “Larry was a good young man.”
“It’s just . . .”
“I know.” There was no condemnation in her voice. “He wasn’t Josh Nelson.”
It almost sounded strange hearing his name now. He was one of the most recognized men in America, a person who’s first and last name were permanently linked together. The kettle began whistling, and Amanda turned off the burner. She poured hot water into both mugs. “Sometimes I feel like I’m waiting for that feeling again, the one I felt with him.”
“Honey . . .” they both knew what was coming. “Young love is like that. It’s wrong to spend your life wanting those feelings again. They come once in a lifetime, and then, only to the very luckiest of us.”
It was something her mother had told her dozens of times. Usually Amanda listened thoughtfully and nodded. But not today. “I guess I don’t understand. I mean if I know love can feel like this,” she raised her hand high over her head. “Why settle for this.” She dropped it back to waist level. “You know?”
Her mother patted the stool beside her. “Come sit down.”
She did, but she was still frustrated. Since she was a little girl she’d prayed about her future, about the man she’d marry. When she met Josh, she was sure he was the one. Never mind that they were young and idealistic, Josh knew her. Really knew her. She took a sip of her tea and looked into her cup. “I’m thinking of taking a few days off, going to the coast.”
“The coast?” Her mother knew nothing about the silly promise she and Josh had made each other that year. “The Oregon coast?”
“Yes. Tillamook.”
“Oh.” Her mother lowered her brow, confused. “Near Twin Rocks?”
“Right.” She brought her eyes to her mother’s. The smell of spicy chicken lingered in the kitchen. “Remember that last summer, when our family and Josh’s went to camp?”
“Yes.” Her mother held her tea close to her face and breathed in the steam. “You were both seventeen.”
“Right, well . . .” The words didn’t come easily, and Amanda felt a decade younger stumbling over the explanation. “We promised that if neither of us saw each other again, and if we weren’t married to other people, we’d meet again the first Saturday in October, 2005.”
Slowly, her mother’s eyebrows lifted high into her brow. “That’s . . .”
“I know. It’s ten days away. October 1st.”
She gasped. “Amanda!” Her eyes showed the hint of a smile. “You’re thinking of going?”
“I am.” She took a burning mouthful of tea and swished it in her mouth. Then she swallowed. “Is that crazy?”
Her mother waited a long time before she answered. “Josh has moved on, honey. I’d be shocked if he showed up. But either way, I don’t think you’re crazy.” She took a slow sip from her mug. “Maybe it’s a trip you have to make. So you’ll learn something about yourself.”
Everything about the conversation with her mother sat well with Amanda except one thing. The part where she said that Josh had moved on. She didn’t have to spell it out. What she meant was Josh had changed. He was different now, a movie star, shallow and given to a playboy lifestyle that would never suit her.
She did one last thing before she went to bed that night. The magazine was tucked away in a drawer now, but she pulled it out and looked at the cover for a long time. Not at the headlines or the girl beside him, but at him. And that’s when she knew her mother was wrong. No matter what Josh’s life was like now, his eyes told the real story.
That somewhere inside he was still the same boy she’d fallen in love with.